Baked with love, shared with heart. a pittsburgh cookie table reimagined for you.
Our Story
Sandy Traynor is the owner of "You Had Me at Butter", hailing from the land of rolling hills and endless pierogies in Western Pennsylvania. She grew up steeped in the vibrant culinary traditions of Eastern Europe. From a young age, she began baking. After four decades of perfecting her craft, she not only honors the beloved customs of her ancestry but also ensures that anyone who approaches her kitchen leaves with a smile (and possibly a butter-induced coma).
Our Services
We proudly offer an exciting selection of local and regional customized baked goods. We also offer amazing event setups that will delight everyone!
Custom Bakes
Whether it be American or European styles, each product will be tailored to your tastes. The cupcakes and cookies are culinary passports that fit on your dessert tray!
Event Setups
The personalized cookie table experience is crafted for local and regional celebrations. What’s a party without cookies? Even the cakes have been known to get jealous!
